SCDAG SCDAG

Statement Regarding Darrius Stewart

Earlier today, DA Mulroy and attorneys from our office met with Darrius Stewart’s father, Henry Williams, and his attorney.

Earlier today, DA Mulroy and attorneys from our office met with Darrius Stewart’s father, Henry Williams, and his attorney.

During our meeting, the attorney informed us that there was information that we may have not been privy to that was uncovered during the civil investigation.

DA Mulroy agreed to review the information the attorney will provide and committed to following up after review.


Read More
SCDAG SCDAG

Shelby County’s New Bail System Goes Into Effect

Shelby County‘s new bail process system goes into effect, February 15. The new system includes the creation of a new bail hearing courtroom, bail hearings with counsel no later than 72 hours after a person’s arrest, and…

Shelby County‘s new bail process system goes into effect, February 15. The new system includes the creation of a new bail hearing courtroom, bail hearings with counsel no later than 72 hours after a person’s arrest, and examination of a person’s financial circumstances prior to a bond decision using the Vera Institute’s ‘Ability to Pay’ calculator.

Under the new system, judges will continue to make decisions in all cases but are encouraged to use secured money bail only as a last resort—as required by Tennessee Law.

Under Shelby County’s prior pretrial system, an arrested person could be held for weeks, months, or even years waiting for their day in court. Additionally, their ability to pay the bail amount was not taken into consideration.

The new bail system comes after a group of local and national organizations—including American Civil Liberties Union and Just City— called for Shelby County judicial and government officials to discontinue bail practices that violate the constitutional rights of people arrested in Shelby County.

In August 2022, Shelby County Commissioners passed a resolution for the new bail process to make the system one of the fairest in the nation.


Read More
SCDAG SCDAG

Former MPD Officer, Preston Hemphill to be Added to Giglio List

The Shelby County District Attorney’s Office will add former Memphis Police Department Officer Preston Hemphill to the Giglio list. Additionally, the Office will investigate all prior and pending cases of Hemphill.

February 13, 2023—The Shelby County District Attorney’s Office will add former Memphis Police Department Officer Preston Hemphill to the Giglio list. Additionally, the Office will investigate all prior and pending cases of Hemphill.

Last week the DA’s Office announced that the five former MPD Officers who are charged in the Tyre Nichols investigation had been added to the Giglio list and that the Office will investigate all of the five officers’ prior and pending cases.

This is still a very active and ongoing investigation. The current charges do not preclude us from adding additional charges as the investigation progresses.

Note: A Giglio or Brady list is a list compiled usually by a prosecutor's office or a police department containing the names and details of law enforcement officers who have had sustained incidents of untruthfulness, criminal convictions, and other issues—placing their credibility into question.

Read More
SCDAG SCDAG

Statement from Shelby County District Attorney’s Office Regarding Gershun Freeman Investigation

In October, the District Attorney’s Office was made aware of the death of Mr. Gershun Freeman, who died while in the Shelby County jail. DA Mulroy immediately called in the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation to investigate Mr. Freeman’s death. Additionally, our Justice Review Unit (JRU) has begun reviewing the details of the investigation.

In October, the District Attorney’s Office was made aware of the death of Mr. Gershun Freeman, who died while in the Shelby County jail. DA Mulroy immediately called in the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation to investigate Mr. Freeman’s death. Additionally, our Justice Review Unit (JRU) has begun reviewing the details of the investigation.

The JRU—who received the medical examiner’s report yesterday evening—will continue their review of the investigation thus far conducted by TBI. The JRU will make a recommendation to DA Mulroy once the investigation is complete.

Because this is an ongoing investigation and has not been completed by TBI or the JRU, this is the only information we can provide at this time.


Read More
SCDAG SCDAG

Statement from Shelby County District Attorney’s Office Regarding Ongoing Investigation in Tyre Nichols Case

Statement: This is an ongoing investigation. The current charges do not preclude us from adding additional charges as more information is presented.

This is an ongoing investigation. The current charges do not preclude us from adding additional charges as more information is presented. We are looking at all individuals involved in the events leading up to, during, and after the beating of Tyre Nichols. This includes the officer present at the initial encounter who has not— so far—been charged, Memphis Fire Department personnel, and persons who participated in preparing documentation of the incident afterward.

The DA’s Office worked extraordinarily swiftly but thoroughly to charge those whose offenses were plain and clear and directly contributed to the death of Mr. Nichols, but in no way is this investigation over.

While we are committed to transparency, we cannot comment on the details of an ongoing investigation or give previews of what charges we may or may not bring.

Our goal remains the same: to seek justice for Tyre Nichols and hold all who contributed to his death accountable. We ask for the public's patience as the investigation continues.

Read More
SCDAG SCDAG

DA Mulroy Provides Statement Following Release of Tyre Nichols Video

The City of Memphis has now released the video documenting the tragic murder of Tyre Nichols. I know the Shelby County community, and the nation, are feeling both the outrage and the deep pain that comes with witnessing these acts of violence. Our heartfelt condolences go out to Tyre’s family.

We know that this is a difficult time, and for some, the video may be hard to watch.The video was released because it was important to the community and to Tyre’s family, as they want the world to be their witness and feel their pain. But as we witness the tragic end of Tyre’s life, I also urge you to remember Tyre Nichols as his family does: with his big smile, skateboarding, and being a loving family member.

The release was delayed because it was important to make sure witnesses spoke first from their memory and nothing else. As D.A., I have always sought to balance out the rightful demands of the community with protecting the integrity of our investigation and prosecution.

It’s my hope that this tragedy can lead to a broader conversation on police reform. Memphis has a number of local community groups and I urge you to support them in their social justice efforts. We also commit to partnering with them and doing whatever we can with our resources to help our community heal.

While we understand and recognize the right to protest, we stand with Tyre’s family who have called for peaceful demonstrations.

While nothing we do can bring Tyre back, we promise you that we are doing all we can to ensure that Tyre’s family, and our city of Memphis, see justice for Tyre Nichols.

Read More
SCDAG SCDAG

Statement from DA Steve Mulroy Regarding Meeting with Family of Tyre Nichols and Video Release

Earlier today, we met with the family of Tyre Nichols— who have now seen the video. Transparency is a priority for the DA's Office, and we understand the public's desire for immediate release. However, it's important that the release does not compromise the investigation.

We're working with the TBI and FBI to expedite that investigation and are consulting regularly with the City of Memphis about the video's release, which we expect will occur this week or next.

Earlier today, we met with the family of Tyre Nichols— who have now seen the video. Transparency is a priority for the DA's Office, and we understand the public's desire for immediate release. However, it's important that the release does not compromise the investigation.

We're working with the TBI and FBI to expedite that investigation and are consulting regularly with the City of Memphis about the video's release, which we expect will occur this week or next.


Read More
SCDAG SCDAG

Statement from Shelby County District Attorney’s Office Regarding Tyre Nichols Investigation

Our office is committed to transparency and understands the reasonable request from the public to view the video footage. However, we must ensure we abide by applicable laws and ethical rules so that we do not jeopardize an ongoing investigation or prosecution. We’re working with the appropriate agencies to determine how quickly we can release the video, and will do so as soon as we can. We’ll be sure to update the public throughout this process.

Our office is committed to transparency and understands the reasonable request from the public to view the video footage. However, we must ensure we abide by applicable laws and ethical rules so that we do not jeopardize an ongoing investigation or prosecution. We’re working with the appropriate agencies to determine how quickly we can release the video, and will do so as soon as we can. We’ll be sure to update the public throughout this process.

Read More
SCDAG SCDAG

Statement from Shelby County District Attorney’s Office Regarding Gary Taylor’s Case

We’ve received several inquiries regarding the case of Gary Taylor, who was charged with First Degree Murder and due to a process error recently released on his own recognizance pending trial. The DA’s Office played no role in the decision to release him.

We’ve received several inquiries regarding the case of Gary Taylor, who was charged with First Degree Murder and due to a process error recently released on his own recognizance pending trial. The DA’s Office played no role in the decision to release him. Per longstanding procedure, the judicial commissioner made an initial bond decision to set “no bond.” Subsequently, a process error resulted in Mr. Taylor’s release. The matter never got to the point where a prosecutor was involved in the bond decision.

It is important to note that Taylor’s release was a mistake and not typical. The error had nothing to do with bail reform generally or the new bail procedure set to start in February. Someone charged with First Degree Murder would not ordinarily be released on his own recognizance.

We understand that a warrant was issued soon after, that the defendant showed up for his court date today, and is now in custody with no bond. The DA’s office will vigorously pursue the prosecution of this case, and will also consult with other officials in an effort to prevent mistakes like this from recurring.

Read More
SCDAG SCDAG

DA Mulroy Delivers 100-Day Address

Read More
SCDAG SCDAG

Statement from Shelby County DA's Office Regarding Whitehaven Gold Club Incident

The Shelby County District Attorney’s Office is looking into the incident between Mr. Mark Coleman and Wesley Caldwell that took place at a Whitehaven golf club on Dec. 3. DA Mulroy has consulted with NAACP Memphis Branch President Van Turner regarding the organization’s released statement calling for an upgrade in Mr. Caldwell’s charges.

DA Mulroy understands the concern of Mr. Coleman’s family, friends, and the community and is looking into the matter to determine if the emerging facts of the case align with Mr. Caldwell’s current charge and bond status. 

As this is an ongoing investigation, this is the only information we can provide at this time.

 

###



Read More
SCDAG SCDAG

Shelby County Man Released After Serving 25 Years of a 162-Year Sentence

Shelby County, TN – (December 13, 2022) – After serving 25 years of a 162-year sentence, a Memphis man will now be released. This comes after Judge Paula Skahan and the Shelby County District Attorney’s Office reviewed and reopened Courtney Anderson’s case. 

Convicted of only nonviolent theft and forgery charges, Judge Paula Skahan and the SCDAG’s Office deemed the 162-year sentence excessive. 

Shelby County, TN – (December 13, 2022) – After serving 25 years of a 162-year sentence, a Memphis man will now be released. This comes after Judge Paula Skahan and the Shelby County District Attorney’s Office reviewed and reopened Courtney Anderson’s case.   

In the late 1990s, Anderson went to jail and was later convicted of multiple counts of theft and forgery charges.  In 2000, the trial sentenced Anderson to 162 years, 11 months, and 29 days.  As a repeat offender, the judge gave the maximum amount of time on each conviction and required the sentences to be served consecutive to each other.

The defendant attempted to appeal his convictions based on excessive sentencing, but the appellate court denied his appeals for procedural reasons, such as not attaching the correct transcripts. 

In April 2022, the defendant filed a pro se motion in Criminal court to “correct an illegal sentence.”  Judge Paula Skahan reviewed the motion and brought the situation to the attention of the SCDAG’s office.  Judge Skahan believed the sentence was technically a

“legal” sentence, but was excessive.  She then requested the SCDAG’s office to investigate what, if anything, could be done.  The SCDAG’s office, along with defense counsel, researched and found a legal ground for reopening the case. 

Tuesday, Judge Skahan reduced Anderson’s sentence to 15 years, an effective time-served sentence.

“This was clearly an excessive sentence, the kind of overreaction that sows distrust in our system and doesn’t make us safer, “said Shelby County District Attorney Steve Mulroy. “I’m pleased to have helped in correcting this injustice. It’s an illustration of the good that reform prosecutors can do.”

Anderson, who was brought to tears when receiving the modified sentence, is now 54-years-old. He explained to the judge that he committed the crimes 25 years ago because of a cocaine addiction but has been clean for decades. Anderson plans to reside in Virginia with his sister and said he looks forward to enjoying the holidays with family.

###

The Shelby County District Attorney’s Office, led by DA Steve Mulroy, serves more than 920,000 Memphis and Shelby County residents. DA Mulroy and his team of prosecutors are committed to a safer and fairer Shelby County. Learn more about the work of the SCDAG’s office by visiting scdag.com.

Read More
SCDAG SCDAG

SCDAG Office Hires Veteran Defense Attorney McClusky to Head Conviction Review Unit

The Shelby County District Attorney General’s Office has hired veteran defense attorney Lorna McClusky to head the office’s new conviction review unit, said Shelby County D.A. General Steve Mulroy.

Oct. 18, 2022 – The Shelby County District Attorney General’s Office has hired veteran defense attorney Lorna McClusky to head the office’s new conviction review unit, said Shelby County D.A. General Steve Mulroy.

The new unit, dubbed the Post-Conviction Justice Unit, will review prior cases for possible errors and false convictions. The Unit will also examine sentences that have already been handed down to assess whether or not those sentences were appropriate, taking into account changes in the law.

Mrs. McClusky graduated from the University Of Memphis Cecil C. Humphreys School of Law in 1994. In 1998 she became a member of the Massey McClusky Law Firm, where she rose to managing partner. She has nearly three decades of experience practicing criminal law, including extensive work on capital cases. “This is an epochal shift for the justice system of Shelby County,” said Mrs. McClusky. “We are looking forward to our Unit advancing DA Mulroy's vision of not merely remedying false convictions, but of creating a stronger legal system built on fairness.”

“Mrs. McClusky brings to the office not only decades of legal experience, but also a proven record of fighting for fairness in the criminal justice system,” said DA Mulroy. “This is a crucial step in getting the new unit up and running, and ensuring that we not only remedy false convictions, but potentially bring to justice the actual perpetrator of the crime in these cases where the wrong person was convicted.”

Read More
SCDAG SCDAG

Focusing On What Works With Juvenile Justice

Dear friends,

As of last week, I’ve been your District Attorney for just over a month – a period of time that has seen this community tested and tried in ways that were literally unthinkable during the campaign.

Dear friends,

As of last week, I’ve been your District Attorney for just over a month – a period of time that has seen this community tested and tried in ways that were literally unthinkable during the campaign.

Yet I have seen firsthand this community’s resilience, its hope, and its care for each other. I want to thank you for the many messages of support and prayerful consideration that I have received. As we move forward, please continue to pray for our partners in law enforcement and victims of violent crime everywhere.

New Hires. Last week, I was very happy to announce that Gerald Skahan and Haden Lawyer have joined our staff. Please join me in welcoming them to the District Attorney’s office.More hires will be announced soon, and we are still hiring – please spread the word.

Working Session On Youth Crime. The elections of both Juvenile Court Judge Tarik Sugarmon and myself clearly indicated that the community is ready for a different approach to juvenile justice. To that end , the two of us recently co-sponsored a Work Session on Youth Crimes. We met experts from here in Shelby County and around the country to discuss various proven prevention and intervention strategies.

We know that the most important thing we can do is reduce the likelihood of any child’s first involvement with the justice system. The data is very clear that any arrest, conviction, and detention makes it vastly more likely that a child will reoffend.

There are a few specific things we’re going to begin working on right away:

• Enhance restorative justice. This practice is about centering victims and making our community whole after crime has been committed. It has reduced repeat offender rates in Nashville and other areas. Properly used, it can reduce recidivism in a humane and cost-efficient way.

• Ask our partners in the state government to fund the kind prevention and intervention strategies that we know will work. This includes everything from ensuring that kids in juvenile custody get a real education to more employment opportunities for children to more robust counseling and therapy services for children and their families, especially after release from incarceration.

• Utilize the right kind of blended sentencing. Simply put, this policy would allow some juvenile offenders to avoid transfer into adult prisons so that they can remain closer to their families. Again, this is about making structural investments that reduce the likelihood of reoffending.

All of the ideas we’ve mentioned here can be done well, or they can be done poorly. We intend to do them well, which means they will take time and they will take sustained investment. They will also take accountability, which is what we now ask of the community – help us make sure we get this work right and help us make sure that we have the resources we need to do what families in Shelby County need us to do.

Working Groups Formed. Improving juvenile justice is one of the topics that will be discussed during the next phase of my transition process. I’ve asked my team to broaden the dialogue about understanding what we need to do and can do with regard to improving racial equity, post-conviction justice, restorative justice, and juvenile justice. Members of the team will be leading Working Groups over the next few months to develop these ideas and come back to me with clear recommendations from the community. Please visit stevemulroyforda.com/join-us if you want to get involved in one of these groups.

An important part of my job is communicating with the public as much as I can about what your District Attorney’s office is doing to keep you safe and ensure equal justice for all. Recently, I had the chance to be interviewed on the Just City for their podcast, The Permanent Record, as well as appear on WKNO-TV’s program, Behind The Headlines. I hope you’ll check them out.

Stay safe and thank you for your support,

Steve Mulroy

District Attorney

Read More
SCDAG SCDAG

Mulroy Transition Team Announces New Working Groups to Advise on Criminal Justice Priorities

A bit more than a month into his tenure as Shelby County’s top law enforcement officer, District Attorney Steve Mulroy’s transition effort is into a new phase.

Memphis, TN - (October 10, 2022) - A bit more than a month into his tenure as Shelby County’s top law enforcement officer, District Attorney Steve Mulroy’s transition effort is into a new phase.

Mulroy today announced the formation of four distinct working groups, each of which will be led by a member of the transition and focused on a specific policy topic that is central to his agenda.

“I’ve asked members of my team to broaden their dialogue with our community about what can be done to improve our criminal justice system,” said Mulroy. “My unconditional priority is protecting the public from violent crime. In order to do that, we need to restore public trust in the system’s fairness. The Working Groups will develop recommendations toward that end.”

The four working groups and their respective leaders are:

Disproportionate Minority Contact, Professor Demetria Frank, Associate Dean for Diversity, Equity & Inclusion, University of Memphis Law School

Post-conviction Justice, William Arnold, Director of the Tennessee Office of Reentry,exoneree

Restorative Justice, Mike Carpenter, former Shelby County Commissioner, Director Of Marketing And Development at My Cup of Tea

Juvenile Justice, Mike Working, founder, Working Law Firm

The working groups will engage local and national leaders on these issues and develop a set of recommendations for the District Attorney, who will share them with the public later this year.

For more information or to get involved, visit stevemulroyforda.com/join-us if you want to get involved in one of these groups.

Read More
SCDAG SCDAG

Shelby County District Attorney Mulroy and Memphis Police Chief Davis Announce Collaborative Cold Case Unit

Shelby County Dist. Atty. Steve Mulroy and Memphis Police Department Chief C.J. Davis today unveiled plans for a collaborative Cold Case Unit. This Unit will aid law enforcement in the investigation and prosecution of unsolved homicide and violent sexual assault cases.

Sept. 30, 2022 – Shelby County Dist. Atty. Steve Mulroy and Memphis Police Department Chief C.J. Davis today unveiled plans for a collaborative Cold Case Unit. This Unit will aid law enforcement in the investigation and prosecution of unsolved homicide and violent sexual assault cases.

According to MPD, cases are typically investigated by the original detective until all known leads have been exhausted. After one year with no new investigative leads, a case may be reviewed and deemed to be cold.

“Our Office is excited to announce the formation of the Cold Case Unit,” said DA Mulroy. “We are ready to get to work with MPD to bring closure to these victims’ loved ones who have waited for far too long. These offenders are still out on the street potentially committing many more crimes, so prosecuting them can prevent crimes down the road.”

Once the Cold Case Unit is in operation, MPD will share cold case files with the Unit, and Assistant District Attorneys will evaluate the files using a checklist to determine solvability. SCDAG investigators will follow up on the cases deemed solvable. In cases where warrants could not be served on defendants, SCDAG investigators will assist in locating these defendants so that they can be prosecuted.

“The Memphis Police Department supports any efforts that will assist in bringing long awaited justice to the many families that have been impacted. This effort may be fruitful and help identify suspects who have committed egregious crimes against members of our community,” said Chief Davis.

The Cold Case Unit expects to receive their first cases to review as early as the end of next week. Eventually, the Cold Case Unit aims to review up to 200 cases per year.

If you have information about a cold case, please contact the Memphis Police Department’s Cold Case Unit at 901-636-COLD (2653) or you can email at ColdCase@memphistn.gov. You can also submit information anonymously by calling Crime Stoppers at 901-528-CASH (2274).

Read More
SCDAG SCDAG

Ezekiel Kelly Indicted in Deaths of Two More Victims of September 7th Shooting Spree

Ezekiel Kelly has been indicted on 26 additional charges related to the September 7th shooting spree, including two homicides, said Shelby County Dist. Atty. Gen. Steve Mulroy.

Sept. 28, 2022 – Ezekiel Kelly has been indicted on 26 additional charges related to the September 7th shooting spree, including two homicides, said Shelby County Dist. Atty. Gen. Steve Mulroy.

A grand jury indicted 19-year-old Ezekiel Kelly on two counts of First-Degree Murder in the shooting deaths of Richard Clark and Allison Parker, as well as 24 additional charges including 5 counts of Reckless Endangerment, 4 counts of Criminal Attempt First-Degree Murder, and Commission of an Act of Terrorism.

“This shooting spree terrorized the community,” said Mulroy. “We will do all we can to see that justice is done.”

He was previously indicted on one count of First-Degree Murder in the shooting death of Dewayne Tunstall. He is being held in the Shelby County Jail without bond.

The case is being handled by Chief Prosecutor Chris Lareau and Assistant District Attorneys Jimmy Thomas, Forrest Edwards, and Brad Reasonover of the District Attorney’s Vertical Team 3 which prosecutes cases in General Sessions Division 11 and Criminal Court Division 3.

Read More
SCDAG SCDAG

Man Indicted in Deaths of Girlfriend, Baby

A Cordova man accused of killing his girlfriend and then throwing their 2-day-old daughter into the Mississippi River earlier this year has been indicted in their deaths, said Shelby County Dist. Atty. Gen. Steve Mulroy.

Sept. 15, 2022 – A Cordova man accused of killing his girlfriend and then throwing their 2-day-old daughter into the Mississippi River earlier this year has been indicted in their deaths, said Shelby County Dist. Atty. Gen. Steve Mulroy.

A grand jury indicted 25-year-old Brandon Isabelle on two counts of first-degree murder, aggravated child abuse and neglect, and aggravated kidnapping. He is being held in the Shelby County Jail without bond.

The body of infant Kennedy Hoyle was never found despite a five-day search by authorities in frigid temperatures along the Mississippi River at the north end of Mud Island.

On the evening of Feb. 1, 2022, police discovered an abandoned car with a broken window at Levi Road and Sedgewick Street in Whitehaven. Nearby they found the body of Danielle Hoyle, 27, who had been shot to death.

Relatives said she had been on the way to meet with Isabelle and that she had their newborn baby with her in a car seat. The baby was missing, however, and when police located and questioned Isabelle, who was married, he told them he had thrown her in the river.

The case is being handled by Chief Prosecutor Eric Christensen and Asst. Dist. Atty. Dru Carpenter of the District Attorney’s Special Victims Unit which prosecutes cases involving sexual and physical abuse of child victims, elder abuse and vulnerable adult abuse.

The SVU was created as an expansion of the multi-agency Child Protection Investigative Team known as CPIT.

Read More
SCDAG SCDAG

Cousins Sentenced to Lengthy Prison Terms for Convictions in North Memphis Murder

Two cousins convicted earlier this year in the 2018 shooting death of a 27-year-old man they confronted outside of a North Memphis convenience store were given lengthy prison sentences Friday, said Shelby County Dist. Atty. Gen. Amy Weirich.

Aug. 28, 2022 – Two cousins convicted earlier this year in the 2018 shooting death of a 27-year-old man they confronted outside of a North Memphis convenience store were given lengthy prison sentences Friday, said Shelby County Dist. Atty. Gen. Amy Weirich.

Criminal Court Judge Lee Coffee sentenced 44-year-old Deonta Baskin to life in prison without the possibility for parole for his first-degree conviction and to an additional 30 years as a convicted felon with a firearm.

Baskin was convicted in 2007 in an unrelated attempted murder case for which he served 10 years of a 24-year sentence. He was paroled in 2017, a year before he was arrested in the North Memphis murder.

The judge also sentenced Marcus Green, 43, to life in prison for first-degree murder, 60 years for attempted first-degree murder, 30 years for convicted felon with a firearm, and 15 years for employment of a firearm in the commission of a dangerous felony.

Following a weeklong trial in July, the cousins were convicted of killing 27-year-old Marceles Scurlock in the late afternoon of May 23, 2018, after they told Scurlock to get off their street when they saw him at a store in the 1600 block of Oakwood Street.

Green also fired at the victim’s girlfriend as she ran inside the store for safety.

Video surveillance showed the three men arguing and Scurlock trying to flee. Baskin grabbed and held him as Green punched Scurlock in the head and pistol whipped him.

Baskin told police that he began firing numerous times when he was shot in the side, apparently by accident by his cousin Green. The video showed Scurlock fall in the street and Baskin firing more shots as he walked away.

Scurlock, who was struck 15 times, was pronounced dead at the scene.

The case was handled by Chief Prosecutor Alanda Dwyer and by Asst. Dist. Atty. Jimmy Thomas of the District Attorney’s Special Prosecution Unit which seeks maximum sentencing for repeat felony offenders.

Read More
SCDAG SCDAG

Officers Justified in 3 Fatal Shooting Incidents in 2021, DA Announces

No criminal charges will be filed against law enforcement officers involved in three separate fatal shooting incidents of fleeing felons that occurred last year, said Shelby County Dist. Atty. Gen. Amy Weirich.

Aug. 26, 2022 – No criminal charges will be filed against law enforcement officers involved in three separate fatal shooting incidents of fleeing felons that occurred last year, said Shelby County Dist. Atty. Gen. Amy Weirich.

In two incidents officers were struck or were nearly struck by the suspects’ vehicles, while in the third an officer was shot in the chest but the bullet was stopped by his protective vest.

The decisions were based on facts, evidence, and statements compiled in comprehensive reports by the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation’s Violent Crime Response Team. The reports then were examined and discussed by the DA’s Officer Involved Death Review Team consisting of Gen. Weirich and five senior prosecuting attorneys.

Before decisions are released, the involved law enforcement agencies are notified, the DA meets with the families of the deceased, and redactions are made to the TBI reports which include thousands of pages and hundreds of photographs.

The TBI reports in each case are available at SCDAG.

The cases include:

o the shooting of Antonio Jackson, 26, on Aug. 16, 2021, at the Robinhood Apartments by a lieutenant with the Shelby County Sheriff’s Office who was trying to arrest Jackson in a narcotics investigation as he sat in his parked car. Instead of surrendering, Jackson drove off, striking the officer with his car. The officer fired two shots before he was knocked to the ground. One shot hit Jackson in the chest, killing him. Inside the car officers found a stolen pistol, marijuana, cocaine and fentanyl. He had $1,900 in his pockets.

o the shooting of Kayla Lucas, 25, by a Memphis police officer on Dec. 15, 2021, outside a McDonald’s Restaurant at 3120 S. Third St. where she was in the drive-thru line in a stolen car. As the uniformed officer approached with his weapon drawn, Lucas put the vehicle in reverse and accelerated, striking the driver’s door of an MPD unit as a second officer was exiting. As that officer jumped back inside to avoid being crushed, a third officer slipped and fell while trying to avoid the suspect’s car as it moved toward him. The first officer fired shots at the driver through the car’s windshield, striking Lucas once in the side. She died at the scene.

o the shootings of Terrance Dogan, 27, and John Henry Taylor, 18, on Dec. 16, 2021, by an Arkansas State Trooper following a high-speed chase into Memphis that ended on West McLemore at I-55. Dogan, who was wanted on violent felony warrants out of South Carolina, fired multiple rounds as he drove past and in front of the trooper, hitting the officer in the center of the chest. His vest stopped the bullet and the trooper fired his duty rifle through his own windshield, striking the fleeing vehicle multiple times. The suspect’s vehicle came to a stop and, after a period of surveillance, Memphis police officers in an armored vehicle found Dogan and Taylor dead. Each had been shot once.

The TBI reports and photographs posted on the District Attorney’s website have been redacted in accordance with Tennessee law and privacy standards. If the officer or officers involved in the death are not charged with a crime, their name or names also will be redacted.

In 2015, DA Weirich, the Memphis Police Department, the Shelby County Sheriff’s Office, and the TBI signed a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) outlining a new procedure in which officer-involved death investigations are conducted.

Under the MOU, the DA is notified immediately when an individual dies at the hands of law enforcement or dies while in the custody of law enforcement, if warranted by the circumstances. The DA, in turn, notifies the TBI and asks them to conduct an investigation.

When the TBI report is completed, it is sent to the DA who will make a decision whether criminal charges should be filed.

DA Weirich initially had to seek permission from Chancery Court to release the reports to the public since TBI investigative files at that time were confidential under state law.

In 2017, however, the state legislature approved a bill allowing TBI investigative records on officer-involved deaths to be made public after the investigation and prosecution are completed.

Read More